Interlay’s Long-term Vision for Interoperability
First, there was Bitcoin. A vision of a decentralized, transparent and better financial system brought to life.
Then there were altcoins. Hundreds of clones and completely new blockchains, trying to solve humanity’s issues with new technology.
Then there were tokens. Thousands and thousands of tokens for everything one might dream of: tokenized assets, DAO votes, cinema tickets, or pet animals. Ownership digitized and decentralized.
And now, it’s all coming together. The multi-chain universe is becoming a reality. Hundreds of blockchain (networks) each with thousands of potential decentralized and tokenized applications built on top.
More now than ever, one of the oldest questions in crypto arises: Among the many, will one rise to rule them all? Or will the many join to become one and rule together?
Interlay: On a Mission to Bridge Networks
Two years ago, we started Interlay with the vision to allow anyone to use any asset on any chain in a truly trustless manner.
- No more centralized custodians.
- No more censorship.
- No more Mt. Gox-like events.
The wise, old “not your keys, not your coins” dogma brought to blockchain interoperability.
Our path began with Bitcoin — the king of all crypto assets. Others tried to engineer DeFi onto Bitcoin. We decided to do the opposite: bring Bitcoin to the exponentially growing DeFi ecosystem.
We built interBTC, Bitcoin on any blockchain. A 1:1 Bitcoin-backed asset, fully collateralized, interoperable, and censorship-resistant. interBTC will bring trustless Bitcoin to any blockchain, starting with Kusama and Polkadot — it’s home-base.
Now, two years later, we take a look…
- at the Past: centralized and custodial bridges;
- at the Now: interBTC, a decentralized and economically trustless but still custodial bridge;
- and at the Future: brave, new non-custodial bridges.
The Past: A Custodial Reality
When a niche becomes an industry, innovation tends to be overshadowed by legacy methodologies — long proven and practical… but legacy. Similarly, the hyper-growth of the cryptocurrency space has caused us to forget the vision that started it all and accept lesser solutions for the benefit of market timing.
Take a moment to look around and you will find the old, centralized ways sneaking their way into DeFi. And interoperability is leading in this category.
Nearly all cross-chain bridges in use today are centralized and custodial. Users give up control over their assets and trust a 3rd party to maintain the bridge — without any repercussions in case of theft or failure, be it as part of a technical security issue or a regulatory event.
Two Types of Bridges
To understand why this problem arises, let’s recall the two main settings / types of cross-chain bridges:
- Smart contract <> Smart contract bridges connect two chains that both support smart contracts. This includes the bridges between Ethereum and Solana, Avalanche, Near, and Polkadot. To this date, most apply a centralized approach, rather than using advanced verification techniques or cross-chain light clients. Few exceptions are Near’s Rainbow bridge and the upcoming SnowFork bridge between Ethereum and Polkadot, which have overcome the technical challenges and made use of the available smart contract functionality to come up with trustless solutions.
- No smart contract > smart contract bridges connect cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin with blockchain / DeFi platforms such as Ethereum, Polkadot, Solana, Cosmos. Without smart contracts on Bitcoin, we cannot programmatically check the state of e.g. Ethereum to lock / unlock BTC. This makes trustless solutions very difficult to build, which is why currently 99.9% of the bridged Bitcoin on Ethereum rests in centralized, custodial accounts (wBTC, renBTC and hBTC).
Interlay’s interBTC falls into the latter category.
interBTC: Decentralizing Custodial Bridges
Clearly, there needs to be a better way to bridge Bitcoin and similar assets. What use is the decentralization of DeFi, if we’re using a centralized bridge to get there? We all know: a chain is only as strong as the weakest link.
Interlay’s interBTC brings decentralization and economic security to custodial bridges. It is based on the XCLAIM protocol, published back in 2018 as a peer-reviewed security paper by Interlay co-founders — with significant practical improvements conceived in the years since then.
To mint interBTC, users lock BTC with custodians — so called Vaults. Yet Vaults are not trusted. They must lock collateral in various assets, such as DAI, DOT, USDC, with the interBTC bridge (more precisely, the Interlay parachain on Polkadot). If a Vault steals or loses BTC, their collateral is slashed — and users reimbursed.
This simple, but effective principle, together with sophisticated collateral balancing, cross-chain verification and governance mechanisms, earns interBTC three key properties:
- Radically open. Anyone can become a custodian of BTC (= Vault), anytime. Anyone can keep their own BTC in custody. Vaults can implement additional security measures like threshold signatures, trusted execution environments, MPC protocols and the like. But they don’t have to. If one Vault goes down, it will not affect the other Vaults in the network. No-one can stop anyone from running a Vault.
- Secured by Insurance. Every custodian of BTC (= Vault) must provide more collateral than the value of BTC they are keeping in custody. Vaults lock collateral on the bridge in various digital assets. If Vaults misbehave, their collateral is slashed and users reimbursed. Users only trust that Bitcoin and the DeFi platform they use are secure.
- Community-owned. Any user and custodian providing liquidity to the bridge (BTC, KSM, DOT,…), KSM/DOT crowdloan contributors, early backers, and builders will steer the success of the network via their governance tokens. They control the collateral assets, economic parameters of the system, and future innovations.
“Why should we care?”
You may ask yourself: “Why should I not simply use one of the existing, centralized wrapped BTC providers? Everyone else seems to be doing it and they’re fine”
The reason is simple.
Because there are more than USD 17 billion worth of BTC locked in centralized, custodial bridges. USD 17 billion that are backed by nothing but trust in a few centralized providers. USD 17 billion that will be instantly worth 0 if the centralized custodians are hacked, subpoenaed, lose their keys, or decide to steal. USD 17 billion that would turn into USD 0 — and cause a cascade of liquidations and failures across the entire DeFi ecosystem, hitting both small and major players (e.g. MakerDAO) alike.
USD 17 billion worth of BTC that stands in contrast to what Bitcoin set out to achieve.
USD 17 billion that could be secured by a decentralized set of collateralized interBTC Vaults. A system, where the worst case scenario, if all Vaults collude and run away with BTC, is that interBTC would be backed “only” by a sophisticated multi-collateral system — and users could get their money back, should they want to.
Indeed: the “worst case” scenario for interBTC, if all BTC is simultaneously stolen, is becoming the equivalent of Maker’s DAI for Bitcoin: a BTC stablecoin backed by multi-asset collateral and price oracles. That doesn’t sound too bad, does it?
Brave New Non-Custodial Bridges
While interBTC revolutionizes BTC bridges, it is still not Interlay’s end-goal.
Attentive readers by now spotted that interBTC is decentralized and economically trustless — but still custodial. Yet, our vision was driven by the “not your keys, not your coins” dogma?
Unfortunately, we have realized and proven that it is impossible to build a fully fungible wrapped BTC asset while keeping the bridge non-custodial. Once again we are forced to choose between usability and security.
But, do we really need fungibility?
However, we have come to realize that this choice is not as bad as it sounds.
If we take a look at DeFi today, asset fungibility is achieved by following standards such as ERC20. Often, however, assets in DeFi actually do not need to move freely: supplying collateral for stablecoins like Maker’s DAI or Acala’s aUSD does not require the collateral asset to be transferable between users. Rather, the collateral asset is locked with a smart contract in a non-custodial manner by the user taking out the stablecoin position.
With this in mind, we started working on a new type of Bitcoin bridge — codename layBTC. LayBTC would not just be a bridge — it would be an entirely new paradigm of using Bitcoin in DeFi, shifting focus from flexibility to security and ease of use.
Imagine: BTC in your wallet while you earn DeFi yield on Polkadot, Ethereum etc. with only 1 click. BTC DeFi not only for the DeFi degens — but for the mainstream user.
We don’t want to tease too much at this point. We’re making good progress and are on track to a release in 2022. Keep an eye on our channels — a few hints, maybe even a technical paper might drop soon.
Outlook: Beyond interBTC
So far, we’ve focused our discussion on bridges, specifically for Bitcoin. However, the technology built by Interlay can be so much more.
As a starting point, the “core bridge” will be expanded in four dimensions:
- Assets. More underlying assets, such as DOGE, LTC, ZEC and any chain where cross-chain light clients are not feasible, can be bridged using Interlay’s technology. We will be encouraging and supporting the community expanding the bridge — it will not only be Interlay who can and will extend the system. Interestingly, the framework works not only for crypto, but also real world assets
- Networks. From Kusama and Polkadot, interBTC and all other bridged assets will be made available to all major networks. The work on Ethereum and Cosmos has already commenced. Others will follow soon.
- Collateral. As a multi-collateral system, a diverse set of backing assets with different risk profiles is critical for security, but also economic efficiency. Interlay will support the community in identifying and analyzing suitable collateral candidates, varying from stablecoins, LP tokens, liquid staking assets, perhaps even NFTs.
- Trust Dimension. Finally, the bridge can be extended to support other, less decentralized trust models. While not the ultimate goal, smaller communities struggling to attract sufficient backing collateral may e.g. opt for hybrid models, where a some level of trust is required but a partial insurance is provided. Communities will be free to use the Interlay Network to bridge other assets in whatever way they feel is best suited. In some cases, e.g. real world assets, a fully trustless setup might not be possible by design.
With the already announced support for smart contracts, tailored to Bitcoin and any other assets bridged via the Interlay Network, bridged based products can be built by the community. Interlay once built a prototype for a decentralized BTC options platform with new forms of trust-minimized leverage — an example of what can be deployed on the Interlay Network and benefit from the available and customizable set of cross-chain functions.
A path of exploration that will be in Interlay’s focus are integrations. The decentralized and trustless nature of interBTC must be accompanied by a simple UX — users should not be forced to choose between security and usability. As such, wallets and on- and off-boarding via exchanges will play an important role in adoption.
Last but not least — my personal favorite area of development: moonshot projects. Every once in a while an idea comes along that has the potential to revolutionize how we use crypto. Many of these turn out to be infeasible or simply don’t work. Yet, by exploring unconventional ideas or attempting to solve impossible challenges, we learn and get a step closer to success with other projects. InterBTC started as a moonshot project. Project layBTC is another. Who knows what we can come up with as a community?
We envision a future where blockchains seamlessly connect and interact: anyone can use any digital asset on any blockchain, trustless and without limitations. We work with Bitcoin, Ethereum, Polkadot, Cosmos and others to expand interoperability, capital efficiency and openness.
Our flagship product is interBTC — Bitcoin on any blockchain. A 1:1 Bitcoin-backed asset, fully collateralized, interoperable, and censorship-resistant, realizing the true free nature of BTC and decentralized finance. Kintsugi is our canary network on Kusama — the innovation hub of the Interlay network.